1918-1939
is sometimes called
“the golden age of aviation”
because of the much
technological advancement
made in aircraft. With
World War II came better,
faster airplanes and
more experienced pilots.
By the time the war
was over, air travel
was becoming firmly
established across the
world. The skies became
the highways of the
future. People started
looking up in curiosity.
What they saw in the
skies was sometimes
mundane, but sometimes
astonishing. The UFO
age had begun.
The
early 1950s saw a surge
of civilian UFO reports.
So serious had the problem
become, that normal
intelligence duties
in the CIA were being
seriously impacted.
Authorities were worried
that if the Soviet Union
or another adversary
attempted to invade
the US, the lines would
be clogged and the government
would be unable to act,
so serious had UFO hysteria
become. Clearly, something
had to be done.
The
CIA responded by forming
a committee to investigate
the thousands of UFO
reports and choose a
course of action. The
committee, headed by
Howard Percy Robertson
came to be known as
The Robertson Panel.
Robertson was a distinguished
physicist, a CIA employee,
and a director of the
Defense Department Weapons
Evaluation Group. He
drew upon six friends
and colleagues of scientific
importance to fill the
panel. Some of the more
famous scientists on
the board were Luis
Alvarez, who won the
Nobel Prize for physics
in 1968; and Samuel
A. Goudsmit, who was
a head of one division
of the Manhattan Project
and jointly proposed
the theory of the electronic
spin. Other members
were Frederick C. Durant,
missile expert; Thornton
Page, astrophysicist;
Lloyd Berkner, physicist;
and Allen Hynek, astronomer.
From
the beginning, the panel
was biased against the
idea of UFOs. In their
first briefing, Robertson
explained that their
purpose was to “debunk”
UFOs. At least one committee
member, Thornton Page,
was reprimanded for
his “excessive levity.”
There has also been
some criticism that,
while the scientists
on the panel were leaders
in their respective
fields, these scientists
specialized in outer
space. No scientists
were consulted who had
expertise in atmospheric
conditions—which is
where UFOs are seen.
The
panel met in secret
for four consecutive
days. During this time
they viewed two amateur
motion pictures: The
1950 Montana and the
1952 Utah UFO Films,
which had already undergone
1,000 man hours of detailed
analysis by Navy officers
who had concluded that
the depicted objects
were not any known aircraft,
creature, or weather
phenomenon. Air Force
Captain Edward J. Ruppelt
and Major Dewey J. Fournet
then addressed the panel,
summarizing the extensive
work they had been involved
with in UFO affairs
over the preceding years.
Ultimately, the panel
spent twelve hours considering
reports and investigations
that Project Blue Book
and other committees
had spent years investigating.
They speedily found
"explanations" for the
reports. When there
was no answer to be
found, they swept the
case under the table.
The
Robertson Panel wasted
no time in formulating
their official report.
They concluded that
90% of UFO sightings
could be readily identified
with meteorological,
astronomical, or natural
phenomenon, and that
the remaining 10% could
be explained with detailed
study. They furthermore
stated that such study
would be a waste of
time. Their final recommendation
stated “That the national
security agencies take
immediate steps to strip
the Unidentified Flying
Objects of the special
status they have been
given and the aura of
mystery they have unfortunately
acquired.”
Based
on their recommendations,
a public relations committee
was assembled to reduce
public interest in UFOs.
Believers subscribing
to such notions were
painted as foolish and
irrational. This effort
drew upon the resources
of renowned scientists
as well as celebrities
and mass media. Even
the influential Disney
Corporation was involved
in the debunking effort.
From this point forward
UFology has been seen
in disrepute among scholarly
circles, and UFOs have
become a subject of
the fringe communities.
Finally,
due to the suggestions
of the committee, groups
studying UFOs were monitored
by government agents
and spies in order to
keep them from influencing
mass thinking. As late
as 1976 a CIA memo was
discovered telling how
the agency was still
having to report on
the activities of UFO
groups.
In
the years following
the Robertson Panel
at least two members
expressed disappointment
with its proceedings.
Because of the panel's
conclusions, the attention
needed to acquire the
data to even decide
the nature of the UFO
phenomenon has not been
given the subject. Thornton
Page and J. Allen Hynek
both lamented that the
subject had not been
treated with more seriousness.
While Page expressed
passing interest, Hynek
went on to become a
scientifically respected
voice in UFology.
There
can be no doubt that
the Robertson Panel
opened the era of government
cover-up regarding the
UFO phenomenon. And
yet, stripped of credibility
and respect, there are
still those who insist
on sharing their experiences.
For no matter the cost,
there are still those
who look up into the
sky with curiosity.
About
the Author:
Francesca Black a long
time science fiction
buff, manages content
for UFO Gifts http://www.ufo-gifts.com
and Science Fiction
Corner http://www.science-fiction-corner.com
|